Review – Bad News Cowboy by Maisey Yates

Posted November 12, 2015 by smutmatters in Contemporary, Cowboy, Reviews / 2 Comments

Review – Bad News Cowboy by Maisey YatesBad News Cowboy by Maisey Yates
Series: Copper Ridge #3
Series Rating: four-stars
Published by HQN Books on July 28th 2015
Genres: Contemporary, Romance
Pages: 384
Format: Paperback
Source: Purchased
Barnes & Noble

Can the bad boy of Copper Ridge, Oregon, make good—and win the rodeo girl of his dreams?
Kate Garrett keeps life simple—working hard, riding her beloved horses, playing cards with her brothers. Lately, though, she feels a bit restless, especially when family friend Jack Monaghan is around. Sexy and shameless, Jack is the kind of trouble you don't tangle with unless you want your heart broken. Still, Kate could always use his help in learning how to lasso someone a little less high-risk…
Jack can't pinpoint the moment the Garrett brothers' little sister suddenly stopped seeming so…little. Now here he is, giving flirting tips to the one woman who needs zero help turning him on. Love's a game he's never wanted to play. But he'll have to hurry up and learn how before the best thing that ever entered his life rides right back out again…

This is the third book in the Copper Ridge series, and I found it to be the weakest. I didn’t dislike it, but I found the connection between Kate and Jack a little forced. In the beginning, I couldn’t really see what the attraction was other than maybe proximity, especially on Kate’s part. I’m not saying Jack wasn’t a great guy, because he was. But he’s also the only man in Kate’s extremely small sphere other than her brothers. It seemed like she was starting to have sexual feelings for the first time in her life, and Jack was there, so she decided he would be the recipient of those feelings. Which was really disappointing. I’ve loved seeing Kate and Jack interact in previous books, so I really thought their story would be great.

Part of the issue I had was one I’ve discussed before. I’m really tired of the virgins. Specifically, I’m really tired of women who went to standard co-ed schools, had plenty of friends, both boys and girls, but never played even one round of spin the bottle so get to their mid twenties without ever even having a first kiss or even held hands with a man, have never masturbated, have no idea how their own body works, and yet go into multi-orgasmic bliss the first time they have sex with the hero. And then go on to decide they’re going to stay with that hero forever and ever. I’m not saying everyone needs to sleep with hundreds of people before settling down, but at this point Kate is only 23. I just don’t see why this needs to be her forever. Jack is 33. The age difference doesn’t matter, but I buy his readiness to settle down a lot more than I buy Kate’s. He’s done his oat-sowing. Kate has never done anything. (And this is specific to Kate. I’m not saying that no 23 year old is ready to settle. I’m sure there are plenty of people who settled down that age or younger and were perfectly content.)

But Kate has never left Copper Ridge. She’s never flirted with a boy, she doesn’t own a computer, she only owns a flip-phone, and she has no idea how to even smile at a guy. She’s really immature, and I just can’t buy that she’s ready for forever. She deals with her new sexual feelings by being bitchy and yelling at everyone around her every time they say hello. It reminded me of a toddler who’s throwing a temper tantrum because he’s tired and doesn’t have the capacity to just say he’s tired. She would yell at Jack, be really nasty, then turn on a dime, kiss him, then start yelling at him again. At the end of the book, she’s decided to go pro on the barrel-racing circuit. So she’s getting ready to leave her hometown for the first time. She’s getting ready to experience so many new things. She’s not going to be the same person when she gets home that she is when she leaves. It doesn’t mean she’s going to come home and suddenly be incompatible with Jack, but who knows. She might. She might realize there are more than 3 men in the world and find someone else. To borrow an analogy from Buffy Summers, Kate is cookie dough. She’s not done baking, and who knows what kind of cookie she’ll be when she’s done.

About Maisey Yates

USA Today Bestselling author Maisey Yates lives in rural Oregon with her three children and her husband, whose chiseled jaw and arresting features continue to make her swoon. She feels the epic trek she takes several times a day from her office to her coffee maker is a true example of her pioneer spirit. In 2009, at the age of twenty-three Maisey sold her first book. Since then it’s been a whirlwind of sexy alpha males and happily ever afters, and she wouldn’t have it any other way. Maisey divides her writing time between dark, passionate category romances set just about everywhere on earth and light sexy contemporary romances set practically in her back yard. She believes that she clearly has the best job in the world.

2 responses to “Review – Bad News Cowboy by Maisey Yates

  1. Sucks it just didn’t work for you. I have no problems with virgins since I know many who went through college and later without having done anything (and not for religious reasons). But I do want it believable if it’s a contemporary especially with what’s out there even just in movies, ya know? So totally clueless doesn’t quite work for me. Hopefully the next will hit the spot a little better 😀

    • smutmatters

      It’s not the actual fact of being a virgin that bothered me so much. I completely understand getting into your 20s still a virgin. It was more that she hadn’t done anything, nothing at all. She had never held hands with a guy or even kissed one on the cheek. She’d never even masturbated and she didn’t even own a computer, so I know she’d never watched any porn, but she turned into a multi-orgasmic sex goddess the minute her clothes came off. She had no questions, no emotional hangups, nothing. She knew exactly what to do and how to do all of it. I’ve read books with 20-something virgins where this was handled better. Victoria Dahl had one recently, but that heroine asked the hero for tips and had at least masturbated so she knew what she would enjoy. In Bad News Cowboy, Kate has absolutely no frame of reference for that but still manages to do everything exactly right and have multiple orgasms. That’t the type of virgin trope that bugs me. But I still really like this series, and I especially liked the first one.